MILTON, Mass. — The play that led to Reece Ayala’s incredible buzzer-beater wasn’t even initially meant for him.
Before the Milton Academy guard made one of the signature shots of the start of the NEPSAC season – a half-court shot to beat Choate on Dec. 15 at the Scholar Roundball Classic – head coach Lamar Reddicks initially drew up a play for Ryan McLaughlin. With the game tied at 62 with 3.0 seconds left, the sophomore guard was supposed to come from the weak side and curl for a 3-pointer.
But the shot was blocked out of bounds. There were 1.4 seconds left on the clock, but Milton had no timeouts. Senior forward Jack Watson, who was inbounding the ball, said he was told to run the same play, which included multiple secondary options. The initial play to McLaughlin was covered by Choate’s defense, and another option included junior guard Devan Williams on a back cut for a lob, but executing that was unlikely.
Watson didn’t panic despite the brief scramble. He knew the game was tied, which relieved some pressure.
“We were just looking for the best shot we could possibly get,” Watson said. “Worse comes to worst, we go into overtime.”
They didn’t need it. As the whistle blew, Ayala made a beeline to Watson on the side with both hands up ready for the ball. He was open, and ultimately Watson’s only option. Ayala got the ball just above midcourt, and immediately put it up over a defender.
“It felt good as soon as it hit my hands,” Ayala said. “I see it going up, and going up, and it just drops.”
“That’s the perfect feeling.”
Thrilling end to @ChoateHoops & @ma_boys_hoops here at the #SRC
2027 guard Reece Ayala capped off his 21 point performance with a buzzer beating three with the game tied from just over halfcourt.
2025 Kiran Makam led Choate with 17 points.
Final score 66-63 @NERRHoops pic.twitter.com/qw5CYmtPIB
— National Prep Championship Series (@PrepNational) December 15, 2024
After it went in, Ayala, in a moment of self-satisfaction, pumped his fists and screamed something to himself.
“I was like, ‘You know who it is,’” Ayala said. “I was feeling myself a little bit.”
A wild celebration ensued, as the entire Milton bench spilled on to the court to mob Ayala. It was a scene reminiscent of last season’s Class A first round game, when Milton, ironically enough, also beat Choate on a buzzer-beater. Still, Watson stood stunned.
“I’m so shocked,” Watson said. “I’m like, I don’t know how that happened. …
“You can see me in the video for a second, I’m standing outside like, there’s no way that just happened.”
The thrilling game-winner served as something of an early-season rallying moment for a Milton squad looking to prove something this winter. The Mustangs went 5-2 entering the winter break, and they’re poised to make some noise despite what they lost after last season.
No team in Class A – and maybe even the entirety of NEPSAC – saw more talent depart than Milton. CJ Cox (Purdue), Nick Petronio (Boston College), Austin Hunt (Harvard) and CJ Happy (Princeton) made up a monster graduating class that helped the Mustangs continue as one of the best teams in Class A, which included a championship in 2023.
There’s no replacing those players, who were the pillars of Milton’s program, but this year’s group – which has just four players in the 2025 class – is motivated despite their youth. With a handful of newcomers, including McLaughlin (Hanover, N.H.) and Williams (Uncasville, Conn.), the Mustangs remain extremely talented. They know what the outside expectations were – that Milton would take a step back after the seniors it lost – but inside, they’re intent on disproving that narrative.
“Coach Reddicks has instilled in us, ‘This is not a rebuilding year, guys. We’re going to show who Milton is,’” Watson said. “I think every game, we kind of have gone in knowing like, he’s put trust in us that we can continue what Milton has been doing. … We felt our chances were just as high as they have been.”
Added Ayala: “I think everyone thought we would drop off, like, Milton isn’t going to be as good, and we all knew that was what everyone was thinking. We all want to prove a point.”
Last season’s senior quartet left a legacy on the court but also left behind valuable lessons. Both Watson (Falmouth, Mass.) and Ayala (Lawrence, Mass.) spoke about the wisdom that was imparted to them. Ayala – a 2027 guard who wants to prove himself as one of the best guards in New England – saw Petronio and Hunt waking up early every morning to get shots up in the gym. He recognized that he wasn’t in the weight room as much as he should have last season, and lifting is a habit now; he said he put on another 10 pounds.
Watson noticed how detail-oriented the seniors were – things like sleep and nutrition habits – and has applied it to his lifestyle. He saw how well they communicated on and off the court, and how it led to success. He’s followed the example of work ethic they set.
“To come in and learn from them was really important and helped me grow my game,” Watson said. “I think for somebody who hadn’t experienced that before, to be able to come in here and see that, it was like, ‘Wow, these are some things that you can control and can really improve your game.’”
On the court, part of why Watson thinks this group has gelled so well is because of how much time they spend together. He said they all love being around each other. It’s not that they didn’t last season, but he noted there was an age gap last year. This season, most of the players are around the same age. They have the same classes and spend most days together.
“I think that helps us play together,” Watson said.
Milton boasts a confident group, one that believes it can make a deep run in a very competitive Class A. That buzzer-beating victory over Choate – one of the better teams in the class – was significant; it represented that they can hang with and beat the best, and it reaffirmed the work and potential this young group has.
Despite what the doubters may say, Milton is dreaming big this winter.
“I think if we really lock in, we can make it to the championship game,” Ayala said. “I think there’s no other team that really has what we have right now, and even if it’s not this year, next year we have a really strong team coming back and we’re going to compete every single year for the championship.”
Added Watson: “I think coming out with that win (over Choate) really boosted our confidence and shows that we as a team, if we keep working like we have been, we can keep going. There’s nothing stopping us, it’s just ourselves and how much we want to put into it and how much we trust coach putting us on the right path, which I 100 percent believe he will.”


