When Cary Herer was hired as CATS Academy’s basketball coach in 2021, he essentially had to build the program from scratch. The school didn’t previously have a high-level basketball team. The gym’s court was made of rubber, and they had to put a new floor down. Even the baskets had to be extended to college size.
But Herer – along with Expressions Elite director Todd Quarles, who helped him start the CATS program – had a vision. Four years later, a big part of their plan has come to fruition.
On Monday, CATS announced it will be joining the Nike Elite Youth Basketball League (EYBL) Scholastic, which is considered the top high school basketball league in the country, starting next season. CATS, the international boarding prep school located in Braintree, Mass., will be the second team from New England (along with Brewster) to join the league, and the first in the Boston area.
It’s a seismic move for CATS, which has quickly transformed into one of the best teams in the region as a NEPSAC member over the last four years. Herer said CATS will now have two high-level teams representing its program – the Nike EYBL Scholastic team and a postgraduate team. Details on the latter have yet to be finalized, but the excitement is palpable for a program that has already evolved to become nationally recognized in its short existence.
“If someone told me CATS Academy would be EYBL Scholastic five years ago, I would have said, ‘You’re crazy,’” Herer said. “It’s an incredible achievement, but we haven’t really achieved anything yet.”
This plan has been about five years in the making. Prior to starting CATS, Herer had joined Expressions as a coach in his pursuit of getting involved with high-level basketball. He and Quarles were looking for a gym to practice in when he found CATS, and they decided they wanted to start a basketball program at the school with a goal of ultimately competing at the highest levels.
Herer said getting into Nike EYBL Scholastic has been a realistic pursuit for the last two years. After spending their first two seasons in NEPSAC Class A, CATS jumped to Class AA for the 2023-24 season. CATS’ bid to get into Nike EYBL Scholastic last spring was denied. But after a strong 2024-25 season in which it won a program record 28 games, made the NEPSAC Class AA championship game and qualified for the National Prep Championship, CATS was accepted into the league.
Herer said CATS upgraded its program to a point that earned Nike’s confidence. They boosted their talent level and proved they can attract top international players. Through multiple presentations, they showed Nike that they have the sufficient infrastructure and administrative support to continue to enhance their program. Herer credited the CATS’ administration as a critical aspect of this move, as the basketball program and school are in lockstep with their goals and mission.
Most of all, Quarles was the key component that pushed this move over the finish line. The founder and director of Expressions Elite, the longtime Nike grassroots program, was instrumental in getting CATS accepted into the league.
“Without Todd, this doesn’t happen,” Herer said. “He’s probably the main reason why this happened. … He’s a huge percentage of the trust Nike puts in him just where he’s at as far as his program.
“We wanted to play in the biggest and best league in high school basketball. We feel like EYBL is the highest level in grassroots and I don’t think there’s an argument. EYBL Scholastic is the highest level for high school basketball. The goal has always been to play at the highest possible level. You strive to play at the highest level possible.”
While CATS is certainly excited about this move, Herer was frank about his mindset; “this doesn’t mean we’re satisfied,” he said. He added it’s one thing to get into the league, but it’s an entirely different challenge to stay in the league and truly compete with the best. Herer said it starts and ends with recruiting.
Herer believes CATS has the right pieces in place to recruit at the highest level. The school’s location, just outside of Boston and a short ride from Logan Airport, is ideal as they continue to recruit the best international talent, which aligns with the school’s mission as an international boarding school. The school’s relationship with Expressions gives potential recruits an opportunity for year-round development, training and consistently high-level competition.
“I think the model that we have lends itself to what Nike is trying to do,” Herer said. “I think we’ve proven that we can recruit international talent. I think now that you say EYBL Scholastic, it gives us a jump on some higher level kids that we haven’t been able to have access to.”
The EYBL Scholastic doesn’t allow fifth-year players, so coupled with the postgraduate team, CATS has its corners covered amidst a changing landscape in which high-level reclassified recruits playing extra years have become more common. With two high-level national teams, CATS’ model is different from most programs; Herer compared their approach to programs like Sunrise Christian and IMG Academy. This move positions them to bring in top talent, and attract coaches and scouts from the highest levels of college and even professional basketball to see them play.
“The biggest thing here is that we now have the platform to recruit at the highest level,” Herer said. “We want to take this from a regional program to a national program, and we want to bring high-major colleges, NBA scouts to New England, which hasn’t been the case unless they’re recruiting a specific player. We think this is a huge thing for the greater Boston basketball community. The first EYBL Scholastic team in Boston, and we are going to promote it that way. But make no mistake, everything is about recruiting.”
Herer believes this move should be embraced by the New England basketball community, because he thinks it will help the rest of the region. Over the last few years, he’s seen New England’s two best prospects in this generation – Cooper Flagg and AJ Dybantsa – leave the region in their prep basketball journey. Herer hopes this move makes CATS, and New England as a whole, a destination for the best talent again.
“We are trying to bring that back where every high-major coach and even NBA scouts needs to come back to New England,” Herer said. “We think that will help not only us, but everybody else. … So, you can expect high-level, high-major talent and potential pros, and the one variable, we’re going to recruit worldwide. The sport is changing worldwide with NIL and agents and even the way European basketball treats the younger generation. We’re going to hopefully be able to make some changes that will help not only CATS, but New England basketball.”


