There aren't many hotter teams in NEPSAC boys basketball than Cheshire to start the 2025-26 season.
The Cats entered the winter break with a 6-1 record, with impressive wins over top NEPSAC Class AA programs like Kimball Union, St. George's and Winchendon. After a sub-.500 season in 2024-25, they're one of the early surprise stories of the NEPSAC season. Cheshire sits at No. 5 in our latest NEPSAC power rankings on the strength of a unique, unselfish brand of the basketball.
Personally, the Cats have been one of my favorite teams to watch so far this winter. Their cutting, passing and shooting is at a high level; they don't boast a high-major, blue-chip recruit, just high IQ players who know how to play together. They're a basketball purist's dream. But if you ask coaches around NEPSAC, they're not surprised. Cheshire coach Jim McCarthy, who's in his eighth season at the school, is one of the most well-respected coaches in the region and has years of experience at the college level, including stints at Williams, Yale and Northeastern, that have made him one of NEPSAC's top coaching minds.
McCarthy joined the HoopWise Podcast during the NEPSAC break to discuss his team's hot start, what has informed Cheshire's unique style of play, the Cats' key players and much more.
Watch the video
Highlights
Are you surprised at all by this start?
McCarthy: “All or most of it. I was confident in the players we had returning, we had kind of a disappointing year last year from a win/loss standpoint, we had guys constantly in and out of the lineup with injuries, I think we finished the season with seven bodies or eight bodies the last couple of weeks, and some of those guys are back, so I think there’s a natural, ‘hey, that’s not how we want to go out,’ mentality. And then for new players in NEPSAC you always, at least for us, we always have five or six, seven new guys, and you kind of lose half your team, so there was also real opportunity for some newer players to come in and make an impact. You never really know how that’s going to blend, but it’s blended, at least at the start, well this year.”
What have your impressions been of Class AA this season? Is it as loaded as you can remember?
McCarthy: “I haven’t looked at it that closely, but you’d be hard-pressed to find a big difference between whoever’s going to be 13th and whoever’s going to be seventh, you know? It might be a couple games or a couple possessions and a handful of games that made the difference. But yeah, there’s good players on every team and there’s good coaching on every team. There’s different styles, which is something I really like where you can say hey, we haven’t seen zone in two weeks and now we’re going to see a ton of zone. … For the kids, you get to see a little bit of everything, and yeah, there’s certainly no nights off. There’s good players, there’s good coaches. There always has been, but I would say we’ve had years where like in college, I feel like we’re the first four out when we’ve been 15-8 or 16-9 or something and we’re like 10th or 11th.”
Listen
The HoopWise podcast can be streamed here and on major platforms, such as Apple Podcasts and Spotify.


