For the first two months of the NEPSAC season, only two teams – Newman and New Hampton – occupied the No. 1 spot in our rankings.
That changes now.
A wild Saturday saw both Class AAA powerhouses go down within hours of each other, and that means there’s a new No. 1 in this week’s rankings, our first edition since the holiday break. Phillips Exeter, which stunned New Hampton at home, returns to the rankings for the first time since the preseason.
Who’s the new No. 1? Where did Newman and New Hampton fall? Where does Exeter fit? Let’s check out this week’s NEPSAC boys Top 10.
1. St. Thomas More (13-2)
Previous ranking: 4
Next game: at Bridgton Academy, Jan. 15, 4 p.m.
The Chancellors move up to the top spot by virtue of all three teams ahead of them losing, as they eased into their return from break with two easy wins – 100-61 over Thetford Academy and 88-67 over Lee Academy – to take their annual Founders Tournament. London Jemison (Bloomfield, Conn.) led the way with 34 points and 25, respectively, in those games. I’m excited to get a closer look at St. Thomas More as AAA play really gets going over the next week.
2. Newman (15-3)
Previous ranking: 1
Next game: vs. Vermont Academy, Jan. 15, 6 p.m.
I’m still the highest on the Cardinals long-term in Class AAA, but a loss typically drops you in the rankings, so I took them down a spot after its close loss to Cushing – its first defeat in regulation this season – in a thrilling game at TD Garden on Saturday night. Newman responded a day later with a convincing victory at home over Darrow, in which the Cardinals out-toughed the Ducks for 40 minutes.
Newman doesn’t possess many flaws, but one point of improvement it’s working on: free-throw shooting. The Cardinals are shooting 59 percent from the line this season, which has been a difference in their losses; they’ve lost by a combined eight points in their three defeats.
3. New Hampton (12-2)
Previous ranking: 2
Next game: at Kimball Union, Jan. 15, 4 p.m.
The most head-scratching result of the weekend came Saturday when New Hampton was crushed in a 66-45 loss to Exeter. It wasn’t shocking that the Huskies lost – Exeter is very good – but in the way they did; they were out-toughed, pushed around and never responded. Head coach Andrew Gale was honest about his team’s no-show effort – “We didn’t get off the bus, and we got punched in the mouth and we turned internally and we got selfish, and we spiraled,” he said – and hopeful that this will be a critical learning experience in a season of high expectations. I’m not concerned about New Hampton; the Huskies have experienced, veteran leadership, and they’re a prideful group that I’m confident will use this as a wake-up call for the better.
4. Cushing (8-3)
Previous ranking: 7
Next game: vs. Massanutten, Jan. 17, 2 p.m. (at Springfield, Mass.)
I wrote in our last rankings – after Cushing lost two games going into break, dropping them to 7 – that I was confident the Penguins would be moving back up at some point because they’re just too good. It didn’t take long. Cushing grabbed a signature win over Newman at TD Garden in a performance that revealed the best of head coach James Cormier’s group; the Penguins played their style, and made tough plays on both ends to get this one. Oh yeah, and that Ryan Moesch kid is pretty good, too. This win should go a long way for Cushing over the next two months.
5. CATS Academy (11-2)
Previous ranking: 6
Next game: at St. Andrew’s, Jan. 15, 5:30 p.m.
The Griffins sat on a tough loss to Northfield Mount Hermon – which head coach Cary Herer described as their worst performance of the season – throughout the break before returning with two resounding wins, a tough road triumph over St. George’s and a dominant home victory over a surging Kimball Union. CATS is playing an unselfish brand of basketball, Jaxson Terry (Acton, Mass.) is heating up and Leo Curtis has his college commitment wrapped up with his pledge to Arizona State, which should clear his mind for the home stretch. I’m ready for another dominant stretch from this group.
6. Vermont Academy (13-3)
Previous ranking: 7
Next game: at Newman, Jan. 15, 6 p.m.
It feels like the Wildcats are lurking in the weeds and ready to pounce. After winning last season’s Class AAA championship and losing some key pieces, head coach John Zall’s group is quietly putting together one of the best seasons in the region. They’re coming off three really good wins – a 86-52 over Tilton, 59-55 over South Kent and 55-34 over Holderness – heading into Wednesday night’s big matchup at Newman. I’m excited to see what Vermont can do in this one.
7. Northfield Mount Hermon (12-3)
Previous ranking: 5
Next game: vs. Hargrave Military Academy, Jan. 17, 6:45 p.m. (at Springfield, Mass.)
The Hoggers eased back into break with a couple of convincing wins over Master’s and Winchendon, but blew a 13-point halftime lead on Sunday against the Hill School for their third loss of the season. NMH didn’t shoot well, and it cost them. Head coach Mike Shelton’s group gets a few days off before heading to Hoophall for two games; a huge test on Sunday against Putnam Science awaits.
8. Phillips Exeter (8-0)
Previous ranking: NR
Next game: at Austin Prep, Jan. 15, 4:30 p.m.
I knew the Big Red were good – they won the Class A championship last season, of course – but I certainly did not expect a 66-45 victory over New Hampton. The score got lopsided after Exeter got hot from deep in a 24-9 game-ending run, but make no mistake; they were convincing from start to finish against one of the best teams in the region, fueled by relentless defensive pressure that the Huskies weren’t prepared for. Time to put some serious respect on this team’s name.
9. St. George’s (8-1)
Previous ranking: 9
Next game: at Thayer, Jan. 15, 4:30 p.m.
The Dragons don’t get punished in the rankings for losing to CATS, a team that was already ahead of them. They actually led for stretches of that one and hung tough late, but they just couldn’t do enough to grab what would have been a significant win. St. George’s missed an opportunity to jump into the Class AA title conversation, but I think this group will get even better as the season progresses, especially as Barrett Loer gets more comfortable after his recent return from an injury. A fun matchup looms this Sunday against Worcester Academy at the Hoophall Prep Showcase.
10. Williston Northampton (7-0)
Previous ranking: 10
Next game: at Suffield, Jan. 15, 4 p.m.
It may not show in the final scores of its wins – 81-60 over Berkshire and 73-58 over Deerfield – but Williston head coach Ben Farmer said his group had to overcome some adversity. Both games were messy, he said, and it was clear that the Wildcats were coming off a two-week layoff with how rusty they played. But they responded nicely. After winning a handful of games against high-caliber opponents to start the season, Williston will be favored in most of its games moving forward; I’m interested to see how they maintain their success, stay engaged and don’t look too far ahead.
DROPPED OUT: Darrow
ON THE RADAR: Darrow, Worcester Academy, South Kent, Kimball Union, Wilbraham & Monson



