The first several editions of the NEPSAC boys power rankings were fairly straightforward. There was some minor jostling in the top 10, but nothing major.
Well, those days are over.
Before NEPSAC teams around New England headed out on winter break last week, there were a few, I’ll say, surprising, results. Three teams in my top five went down at the Basketbull event that took place at University of St. Joseph’s – and that created some very difficult decisions. I honestly went back and forth a lot with these rankings.
In making my power rankings, I do my best to balance teams’ full body of work with their current form. I fully understand that not everyone will agree with these, but that’s the point: to create debate.
Let’s dive into the rankings.
1. Newman (13-2)
Previous ranking: 1
Next game: vs. Our Savior Lutheran OTE, Jan. 9, TBD
The Cardinals hold on to the top spot after their head-to-head win over New Hampton before they decisively won their two games at Basketbull over Hun School and IMG Select. It doesn’t get easy when they come back from the break. On Jan. 11, they’ll face Cushing at TD Garden in the annual Andrew James Lawson Foundation Invitational before taking on Darrow the next day. That begins a gauntlet of a second-half schedule that includes tough NEBL and NEPSAC Class AAA competition.
2. New Hampton (11-1)
Previous ranking: 2
Next game: vs. Darrow, Jan. 10, 6:30 p.m.
The Huskies got an extra week off for break – their last game was a Dec. 15 win over Lee Academy – and will be welcomed back in January with a difficult stretch that includes Darrow at home and then Phillips Exeter on the road in less than 24 hours before a road test at surging Kimball Union a few days later. I’m interested in how New Hampton’s complementary pieces – beyond their big three of Keyshuan Tillery, Mason Blackwood and Naz Meyer – continue to make an impact, because they will be needed for the Huskies to reach their goals in March.
3. Darrow (10-3)
Previous ranking: 6
Next game: at South Kent, Jan. 8, 6:30 p.m.
This is where things get interesting. After losses around the middle of the previous top 10, Darrow got the nod at No. 3 when the dust cleared. The Ducks hung tough with Putnam Science before dominating Loomis Chaffee and knocking off Cushing to go into the break on a strong note. But the margins from spots 3-7 are slim right now, in my opinion. Each of these teams can beat the other on any given night as they’ve shown, so I’m prioritizing recent form as best as I can. I also believe there’s a gap between Newman and New Hampton and the rest right now, but Darrow can prove me wrong, since the Ducks face both of them on the road the weekend they return.
4. St. Thomas More (11-2)
Previous ranking: 3
Next game: vs. Thetford Academy, Jan. 10, 5 p.m.
The Chancellors suffered a bad loss to Class B opponent Canterbury, falling 81-78 in overtime as they headed into break with a thud. Credit to Canterbury, which effectively slowed down St. Thomas More star London Jemison and fought back after trailing in the final minute of regulation, but that’s certainly not a loss the Chancellors wanted to sit on during the holidays. I only dropped them to 4, though, knowing they’re much better than what they showed.
5. Northfield Mount Hermon (10-2)
Previous ranking: 7
Next game: at Masters School, Jan. 8, 5 p.m.
The top of NEPSAC Class AA is wide open, as evidenced by the results at Basketbull. NMH lost by 14 to Cushing, but responded with two really good wins – 57-54 over CATS in a really physical game, then 70-54 over Brimmer & May. Again, any of these teams – especially this group of NMH, CATS and Cushing – can beat the other on any given night. NMH also has one of the best wins of the season with a victory at Blair Academy earlier this month. Despite that Cushing loss, I still like the Hoggers the most out of that AA group – right now.
6. CATS Academy (9-2)
Previous ranking: 5
Next game: at St. George’s, Jan. 8, 4 p.m.
CATS’ winning streak was snapped at eight games with its loss to NMH, but there’s no shame in that defeat. I’ll put them a hair over Cushing right now even with its head-to-head loss to the Penguins at the start of the season. CATS led for most of that game before Cushing stormed back in the second half. I’d love to see a rematch.
7. Cushing (7-3)
Previous ranking: 4
Next game: vs. Reason Prep, Jan. 8, 5:30 p.m.
It was difficult to figure out where to place Cushing. Yes, the Penguins hold head-to-head wins over both NMH and CATS, but going into the break with two straight losses – including a 10-point defeat to Kimball Union – sends them to 7 here. Again, they’re almost interchangeable with NMH and CATS, and these rankings are very fluid. I’m confident Cushing will be moving back up at some point; they’re too good.
8. Vermont Academy (10-3)
Previous ranking: 8
Next game: vs. Tilton, Jan. 10, 6 p.m.
The Wildcats went into the break feeling very good about themselves with a strong 88-75 win over a talented Worcester Academy team. 2027 guard Kamari Whyte continued his stellar winter with 26 points in that win, while Isiah Rose chipped in 19. I’m really excited to see what kind of noise Vermont Academy can make in Class AAA the next few months. The defending champs are flying a bit under the radar, but as they continue to gel and develop, I think they can challenge the top two.
9. St. George’s (7-0)
Previous ranking: 9
Next game: vs. CATS, Jan. 8, 4 p.m.
The Dragons had some purely dominant wins at Basketbull – including a 31-point drubbing of Masters and 35-point blowout over IMG Elite – but their first big test comes when they return from the break. A home matchup with CATS is a great opportunity for St. George’s to show it belongs in the Class AA championship conversation.
10. Williston Northampton (5-0)
Previous ranking: 10
Next game: vs. Berkshire, Jan. 10, 5:30 p.m.
I was beyond bummed that Williston’s game against defending Class A champion Phillips Exeter was postponed on Dec. 20 because of snow. The game was scheduled to be played at Dexter Southfield as part of the Class A showcase, but Williston couldn’t make it because of extreme traffic due to the conditions. It was another opportunity for Williston to establish itself as a Class A frontrunner, but the Wildcats already have a resume that proves that. It’s unclear if that game gets rescheduled, but if it doesn’t, let’s hope we can see it in the Class A playoffs.
On the radar: Kimball Union, Worcester Academy, South Kent, Phillips Exeter, Millbrook


