The Class AA boys championship race took a twist last month when NEPSAC ruled that NEBL teams are unable to compete in this year’s playoffs.
That meant Cushing and Tilton, two teams I would have picked at the top of the class, aren’t eligible. Brimmer & May, which impressed during NEBL opening weekend, would have certainly been in the playoff mix as well.
The loss of those three teams from postseason eligibility means there’s some more opportunity. The 11 remaining eligible teams will compete for eight playoff spots, and the race promises to be as competitive as ever. One thing’s for certain: There will be a new champion in Class AA in 2026-27 with defending champion Cushing out of the hunt.
As the season gets started, I have your bulletin board material: Here are my preseason championship and playoff predictions for Class AA.
Championship prediction
The pick: St. George’s
Runner-up: Kimball Union
Darkhorse: St. Andrew’s
With Cushing out of the picture, I’m locking in St. George’s as the title favorite. The Dragons were last season’s No. 2 seed before losing in a semifinal thriller to Cheshire. There’s significant continuity and experience and head coach Dwayne Pina deserves more credit for building one of the most consistently successful programs in the region. They have back-to-back ISL titles on their resume and lost only four games last season.
I struggled with the order of teams behind St. George’s and I think you can make a reasonable case for at least five more teams to make a run to Super Sunday. But there are truly no nights off in this class. I think we could see a chaotic winter in Class AA.
Playoff projection
1. St. George’s
Last season: Class AA semifinals
Pina has a core featuring Ethan Njenga (Lowell, Mass.), Adriel Cantave (Carver, Mass.), Chance Finlayson (Newport, R.I.), Columbia commit Otis Crosby (Barrington, R.I.) and Brown commit Jelani Middleton that has been through the trenches together and won titles in the ISL. And I’m not the only one who thinks Finlayson, the top 2029 prospect in New England, is due for another leap after he was a significant contributor as a freshman before having an impressive AAU summer. The Dragons also boast a deeper bench than before. Their depth, experience and variety make me confident in a championship run.
TEAM PREVIEW: Is St. George's primed for another ISL repeat?
2. Kimball Union
Last season: Class AA semifinals
The Wildcats have a new-look roster that may take some time to gel together, but I have faith head coach Cory McClure – who had guided them to consecutive AA semifinal appearances – will get this group peaking when it matters. The 2028 backcourt of Ian Van Wagner and Jackson Perri will be among the best in this class, and McClure built a roster of versatile, dynamic prospects, including 6-foot-7 NJIT commit Adam Anwar, 6-foot-6 2028 forward Jackson Green, 6-foot-5 guard/wing Charlie Pomis and 6-foot-9 Hoosac transfer Daniel Balde-Hernandez. The floor of this group is high and the ceiling is certainly championship-level.
3. Winchendon
Last season: Class AA quarterfinals
I’ve hyped up Winchendon’s backcourt quite enough, and for good reason. The group of Albany commit Treddy Faison, Le Moyne commit Tavin Penix, Columbia commit Lucas Lau and Jayse Johnson could be the best in this class, and they’re all capable of going off on any given night. But the Wapiti also have a strong frontcourt with similar versatility that they had last year. Wyatt Klein and Brady Moore are two bigger wings who can make shots while Jack Burley gives them rim protection that they lacked last year while doing some of the dirty work inside. I like the balance of coach Alex Popp’s team, which has great leadership, talented playmakers and efficient scorers, and they should be well within the title hunt.
CLASS AA: 10 candidates for Player of the Year
4. St. Andrew’s
Last season: Class AA quarterfinals
I’m hearing some preseason buzz about St. Andrew’s and buying the excitement. The Saints were within minutes of an upset over St. George’s in last season’s playoffs and they brought back several of those players. There are seven 2027s on this roster, including co-captain Elijah McNair (East Providence, R.I.) and two of NEPSAC’s most promising 2028s in 6-foot-7 guard Malachi Odugbela (Providence, R.I.) and 6-foot-8 big man Lorcan Bailey Morrow. If Odugbela – who had a huge breakout summer with BABC and is one the captains at St. Andrew’s – takes the leap I think he can, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the Saints playing on Super Sunday.
5. Cheshire
Last season: Class AA runner-up
I want to see what this version of the Cats looks like with three core pieces from last year’s team – John Spinoso, James Caldarella and Justin Brown – graduated. But there are three significant returners in Aidan Maguire, Mercyhurst commit Christian Zarzyzki and Babson commit Chase Leonardo, plus returner Lorenzo Spence to feel good that they’ll be at least a playoff team again. Hamilton commit Mike Wede, do-it-all forward and WPI commit Josh Bergeron and versatile guard Charles Avallone will all be part of the equation, too. Cheshire won’t have a ton of size outside of the 6-foot-9 Spence, but they once again have dynamic guards that will once again pass and cut on teams at a high level. After last season, I’d be a fool to count out a team coached by Jim McCarthy.
6. MacDuffie
Last season: Missed Class AA playoffs
Health will be a critical factor for a Mustangs team that will go at least eight deep, but the upside is enormous. There’s great size and athleticism with newcomers Luke Scarff and Larry Brown in addition to returners Andrew Adegbite and Xavier McCall (Belchertown, Mass.), and Keyshon Joyner (Worcester, Mass.) is among the guards I’d trust the most in New England. With how last season ended plus the fact there aren’t any committed players – yet – on this roster, there will be plenty of motivation at MacDuffie. They have the personnel to break through and make some noise in AA.
7. Worcester Academy
Last season: Missed Class AA playoffs
The Hilltoppers – winners of three AA championships in this decade – had a rare playoff miss last season and I’m not seeing that happen again. I really like the frontcourt versatility of Dartmouth commit Cole Blackburn (Winchester, Mass.), Kai Johnson and Gavin Wettlaufer, and the backcourt is underrated with Jojo Reyes (Worcester, Mass.), Chris Vinson and Jayden Gibson (Stoughton, Mass.).
8. Albany Academy
Last season: Class AA quarterfinals
The Cadets impressed enough to earn a playoff berth in their first NEPSAC season last year, and while they did lose star Jack Louridas to Yale, coach Jim Driggs has an intriguing mix of newcomers and returners. Yale commit and 6-foot-10 center Isaac Gonda gives them a unique inside presence, and newcomer JJ Osinski should be one of their top scorers right away. Elijah Taylor, who just committed to Wesleyan, was one of the most impactful guards in Class AA last season and Frederick Gunn transfer Jah Reaves should give them a two-way boost. Don’t sleep on this squad.


