Saturday’s NEPSAC boys semifinals includes a slate of tantalizing matchups featuring rematches and the best teams in the regions. There will be teams looking for some revenge on top of the high stakes that this stage brings.
It makes predicting these games so difficult. But when it comes to making picks for these playoffs, I’m off to a hot start.
Forgive the quick victory lap. In Wednesday’s quarterfinals, I correctly predicted 13 of the 16 matchups from Class AAA through B, but where I really surprised myself were the score predictions. In a handful of games, I was only a few points off. My prediction for Cushing over Lawrence Academy was an 83-68 score. The actual score was 81-67. My prediction for Kimball Union over Northfield Mount Hermon was 72-68. The actual score was 70-68. My prediction for Phillips Exeter over Milton Academy was 77-67. The actual score was 76-64.
Not bad, right? Let’s see what I can do for an encore. Here are my predictions for Saturday’s semifinals.
FOLLOW THE BRACKETS: Class AAA | Class AA | Class A | Class B, C Large, C Small
Class AAA

No. 1 New Hampton vs. No. 4 St. Thomas More
I was really impressed by St. Thomas More in its quarterfinal win over Vermont Academy, using a hot start and never looking back. It showed the Chancellors’ maturity after an inconsistent close to the regular season, and that they can without star London Jemison making a huge impact. But they are going to need him for this one. New Hampton looks to be on a mission after its 115-64 first-round win over Hoosac, and I’m not sure the Huskies can be stopped.
New Hampton went 20-for-39 from 3-point range in Wednesday’s win, and while I don’t expect a similar output, the Huskies have so much firepower and don’t necessarily need to get hot from deep to win. They did most of their damage inside in their 100-83 win over St. Thomas More in the regular-season finale last week. The Chancellors will be motivated after dropping both regular-season meetings, and it will be important for them to get more contributions from guards Tahlan Pettway and Shuto Sakihama. But New Hampton has too much talent and experience in this spot.
Prediction: New Hampton 88, St. Thomas More 79
QUARTERFINALS RECAP: 20 takeaways from first round of NEPSAC playoffs

No. 2 Newman vs. No. 3 Darrow
I wouldn’t have expected this to be a toss-up when I saw Newman handle Darrow by 19 back in January. But the Ducks have gotten progressively better over the course of the winter, stamped by a home win over Newman last week, and the Cardinals have looked mortal lately. They struggled early with Bridgton on Wednesday before eventually pulling away.
Darrow will enter the Track at New Balance with a lot of confidence, and I expect this to be a battle. The key for the Ducks, for me: They need to do the little things and out-tough Newman, especially on the glass, and Teshaun Steele will likely be tasked with trying to wear down Lucas Morillo. Ultimately, though, I think Newman’s depth and comfort level at home is the difference.
Prediction: Newman 84, Darrow 77
Class AA

No. 1 Cushing vs. No. 5 Worcester Academy
This is a rematch of Cushing’s regular-season finale, an 89-75 Penguins win in which Ryan Moesch was terrific with 19 points and nine assists. I’ll be curious how Worcester Academy’s Amir Jenkins performs; the star junior was mostly held in check in the regular-season meeting as Cushing’s defense forced him into tough jump shots. The Hilltoppers found success with hot shot-making from Jake Blackburn and Connor Swider, and I think they’ll need that again in a difficult environment. Cushing hasn’t lost at home this season, and while Worcester is a worthy challenger with a lot of firepower, it’s hard to pick against the Penguins, their elite defense and Moesch to put them over the top.
Prediction: Cushing 86, Worcester Academy 75

No. 2 CATS vs. No. 3 Kimball Union
CATS won the lone regular-season meeting over Kimball Union, 80-52, at home back on Jan. 12, but two months later, these teams are a bit different. CATS lost second-leading scorer Jaxson Terry to a wrist injury, and Kimball Union is rolling with a healthy group and having figured out the right rotations. The Wildcats’ backcourt of Brandon Arnold and Christian “Mouse” Williams is clicking, and big men Merrick Smith and Zay Henderson, even though they’re a few inches shorter, can bother CATS 7-footer Leo Curtis. But CATS, even without Terry, still has the superior talent with Jaylen Harrell, and Curtis is continuing to get better and more aggressive inside. Jaylin Williams-Crawford will ultimately be the difference in slowing down Kimball Union’s attack.
Prediction: CATS 76, Kimball Union 66
Class A

No. 1 Williston Northampton vs. No. 4 Choate
While Williston has gone a perfect 16-0 in Class A play this season, the Wildcats have had a few close calls. One of them came on Feb. 12, when they hung on for a 63-62 home victory over Choate after Preston Edmead’s 3-pointer in the final minute gave them the lead for good. The Wild Boars will certainly carry some confidence into the rematch, but for Williston, that victory was an important wake-up call, and they won't be underestimating Choate. Edmead, who scored 31 on Wednesday against St. Paul’s, is the difference-maker to lead the Wildcats to Sunday’s championship game.
Prediction: Williston Northampton 67, Choate 61

No. 2 Phillips Exeter vs. No. 3 Tabor
This is the matchup I’m excited most about across Saturday’s schedule. It’s a rematch of Feb. 8, when Tabor handed Exeter its first loss of the season in decisive fashion, 78-53. But as I’ve written and said several times since, that result needs further context. Tabor certainly deserves credit for a terrific performance that day, but it was also Exeter’s first game without star point guard Tyler Bike, who was lost for the season that week after he suffered a torn labrum. In fact, Exeter didn’t even learn until the night before the Tabor game that Bike was done for the year. The Big Red had not practiced or prepared without him, and they were still processing the situation.
Exactly a month later, Exeter has had appropriate time to prepare without Bike. Tabor is still rolling and playing with a ton of confidence after blowout wins over St. George’s and Loomis Chaffee. It has the makings of what should be an intense and emotional rematch. Bike’s absence levels the playing field, but Exeter still has Ryder Frost and home court, where it hasn’t lost this season.
Prediction: Phillips Exeter 73, Tabor 72
Class B

No. 1 Millbrook vs. No. 5 Rivers
There should be equal amounts of motivation from both sides in this one. Millbrook lost to Rivers in last season’s Class B championship game, and Rivers lost to Millbrook earlier this season, which dropped the Red Wings to 0-6 at the start of the season. But despite the seed difference, Rivers has been just as good, if not better, since. The Red Wings are 18-2 since, and Andrew Alekseyenko – who was out injured in that loss to Millbrook – is back and playing well. His presence in the frontcourt will be important to match up with Zoumana Traore and Amadou Fall. Ultimately, it’s foolish to bet against this Rivers team in March. The Red Wings have been in so many big games together, and that experience is a huge difference-maker.
Prediction: Rivers 70, Millbrook 66

No. 2 Canterbury vs. No. 6 Brooks
You almost have to throw out the seed when it comes to this time of the year for Brooks; they seem to always find a different level in March, which showed in Wednesday’s upset win over Pomfret. Alex Wilkins, who missed the start of the season with an injury, is in one of the best grooves of any player in the region right now, and complimentary pieces like Emersen Davis and Riley Clarke are stepping up around him. Brooks also has one of the best groups of traveling fans in NEPSAC, and I’m certain they’ll show up in Connecticut. But this is a tough matchup. Canterbury is one of the best defensive teams in Class B, with size, depth and versatility that can wear teams down, and they have two studs in Andreo Ash and David Dix. Wilkins’ individual brilliance should keep Brooks in this for a while, but I think Canterbury just has a little more.
Prediction: Canterbury 71, Brooks 62


