Hours after they had secured a marquee win, Northfield Mount Hermon head coach Michael Shelton and his team were standing outside in the cold. It was around 6 a.m. Sunday morning on Dec. 8, and NMH had been evacuated from its hotel in New Jersey because of a fire alarm.
At first, Shelton didn’t think much of it. He didn’t see a fire, and he thought there was a chance someone might have been playing a prank.
“Obviously, it wasn’t one of my kids because they’re dead asleep right now,” Shelton said. “You’re like, ‘What knucklehead is playing a joke and pulling the alarm?’
“You feel like it’s going to go off soon, but it kept going and going.”
Little did Shelton know how the rest of his morning would transpire. It included hours of waiting, his team sleeping at a diner and the hotel eventually being declared a crime scene, all while Shelton and his team frantically tried to figure out how to prepare for a 12:15 p.m. game – at a gym 40 minutes away – in which their normal gameday routine was thrown totally out of whack.
Days later, after NMH had won the game under the most unfathomable circumstances, Shelton could only laugh.
“It’s one of those things you can’t really make up,” Shelton said. “It was a crazy experience.”
NMH was in New Jersey to compete in the annual Blair Coaches vs. Cancer Classic hosted by Blair Academy on Dec. 7 and 8. In its opener on Saturday night, NMH handed Blair – one of the top prep teams in the country – its second home loss in seven years. It was a big-time win for Shelton and his team as he continues to build the program back up in his third season.
MORE: NMH's Jaylen Hunter-Coleman was one of several standouts at Scholar Roundball
After getting dinner, it was about 11:15 p.m. when NMH got back to its hotel in Denville, N.J. The plan was for the team to sleep in a bit, hold a team meeting at the hotel at 10 a.m. and then head out at around 10:30 or 10:45 to go back to Blair for its 12:15 game against the Hun School. Those plans were quickly ruined by the 6 a.m. fire alarm.
The team had safely exited the building and huddled together away from the hotel – though one player had shorts on – and after waiting for about a half-hour, Shelton asked one of his assistants if they had the key to their bus. They did, and the team got on the bus to warm up as they continued to wait out the fire alarm.
“Your brain’s barely working, you haven’t had any coffee, you’re like, ‘What are you going to do now?’” Shelton said.
Without a timeline from the hotel on when they’d be able to get back in the building to collect their belongings, Shelton drove to a gas station to get gas for the day, grabbed some coffee from Dunkin’, and assessed the situation. It became clear that it wouldn’t be resolved quickly, so they went across the street to a diner.
There, most of the team passed out and started sleeping in the booths. Some of them ordered food. Shelton continued to call the hotel looking for more information.
“Thirty minutes goes by, 40 minutes goes by, an hour, an hour and a half, they’re not telling us if the problem is solved,” Shelton said.
Around 8 a.m., the hotel told Shelton that police were escorting people back to their rooms to get their stuff. He left to go back, and he was stunned at the scene when he got there. Shelton estimated there were seven fire engines and 20 police cars outside the building, when there were only a handful before.
“You would have thought the whole building burned down,” Shelton said. “They caution-taped the whole front of it off.
But then there was even more confusion and waiting.
“By the time we get back to the hotel, I’m like third in line, they tell us all bets are off, the police chief now calls it a crime scene,” Shelton said. “People had been sneaking in, so they shut the building down.”
MORE: There's a new No. 1 in the NEPSAC boys power rankings
Shelton continued to wait by himself in the cold for about 45 minutes while the rest of the team was at the diner. At one point, the police asked him if he needed a bag. “I was like, ‘Actually I need 15 bags. They were like, ‘We can’t do that, sorry, you’re going to have to wait another hour.’”
Shelton went back to the diner, and at 9:30, they finally got the message that they were cleared to return and get their things. By 10, they left the hotel, and by 10:45, almost unthinkably, they were at Blair to play the game. But the pregame preparation they had planned went totally out the window.
The initial, pre-alarm plan was for NMH to go over film of Sunday’s opponent and do a walkthrough at the hotel. But because of the situation, all their computers were in the hotel rooms. As they waited throughout the morning, they had nothing to show the kids, and most of them were asleep anyway.
“I’m trying to figure out frantically how we’re going to prepare for this game at 12:15 while taking care of the kids in less than six hours with literally nothing to show the guys and nothing for us to watch other than what we had access to on our phone,” Shelton said.
Shelton didn’t even have Hudl, a website many coaches use for game film, downloaded on his phone. He watched film edits on his phone, but it wasn’t something he could show his team. Shelton had to think on his feet about how he was going to structure pregame to give his team the best chance to be successful.
Shelton did his best to keep it as routine as possible. When they got to the gym, he let his team get as comfortable as possible. They got settled in the locker room, saw a trainer if they needed to and got some shots up. And without time to walk through plays or go into detail about their opponent, Shelton simplified everything as much as he could. He went over their offensive and defensive cues, and talked through some of their opponent’s plays instead of walking through them like they would at the hotel. He applied the same game plan they did the night before against Blair to give them some consistency.
“For me, it’s about not overloading them with too much information,” Shelton said.
MORE: How Northfield Mount Hermon is approaching its 2024-25 season
Almost poetically, Shelton said the team slept walk through the first quarter, but they eventually woke up. NMH surged in the second and third quarters behind big games from Nasir Rodriguez and Vincent Chaudhri, and held on late – overcoming some understandable mental fatigue – for something of an improbable victory.
“I’m not saying it was duck-taped or super-glued, man, but we were just trying to get through that game,” Shelton said. “I’m really proud of our guys for the resolve they showed. …
“I’m just glad that our weekend and our big-time win (over Blair) wasn’t spoiled by a stupid fire alarm at 6 o’clock in the morning.”
That’s an important point for Shelton, who believes NMH – which has won three straight games since that crazy weekend – isn’t getting the respect it deserves nationally. Blair was ranked in the Top 10 of the national prep poll when they beat them.
“We feel slighted in that poll,” Shelton said. “We feel like we’re much better than what people are giving us credit for.”
Just as importantly, the experience was an important moment of beating adversity for NMH. Shelton knew he had a talented squad coming into the season, but also knew how they came together as a group would define their season. At one point in the morning, Shelton told his team that if they wanted to go home, he was fine with that.
Their response?
“They were like, ‘Coach what are you talking about? We’re playing the game,’” Shelton said. “They all banded together and came together. …
“I think it’s a testament to our togetherness and our toughness and these kids’ resilience. … You build those moments in practice so that when you face them in a game, whether it’s on the road or you’re getting a tough whistle or there’s a fire at 6 o’clock in the morning in your hotel, you’re just able to figure a way and find a way.”


