STOW, Mass. — John Carroll couldn’t help but laugh. He couldn’t hide his wry smile.
It was the 2022 NEPSAC boys Class AAA championship game, and Carroll’s Northfield Mount Hermon team was in yet another battle with Jason Smith’s Brewster squad. And in the heat of battle, Smith had some fun with his longtime rival.
Smith took one of Carroll’s favorite plays and used it against him. It was a reverse stagger off an action that frees up a shooter for a 3-pointer. Carroll knew it as soon it developed. Years later, he admits they ran it beautifully as Reed Bailey found himself wide open from the wing and drilled the triple.
The scorer’s table was small enough that Smith and Carroll stood by their benches only about 7 feet apart. Smith casually turned to Carroll.
“I said, ‘Did I run that right?’” Smith said, and Carroll responded with a snicker.
“I just nodded my head and I said, ‘Yes Jason, you ran it right,’” Carroll said. He knew he didn’t say disrespectfully. It was just gamesmanship. “I just had a smile, like this (expletive).”
“I was pissed and laughing. I knew he got one on me.”
When Smith and Carroll shook hands after Brewster’s NEPSAC championship victory, little did they know it would be their last time coaching against each other. Four years later, they would be teaming up.
For more than a decade, Smith and Carroll battled at the highest level of high school basketball, leading two of the best teams in the country. They agonized and worked tirelessly figuring out how to beat the other as they routinely played in New England championships, national championships and high-stakes games. Then, this spring, they joined forces.
Carroll, the director of basketball at Masters Academy International – New England’s first sports academy that opened this fall – hired Smith from Brewster as head coach. Together, two of the greatest coaching minds in New England history are shaping the next chapter of prep school basketball in the region.
Rivalry days
Brewster was already an established power when Carroll and NMH met them for the 2010 national prep championship. Carroll lost that day when Brewster star Will Barton put on a show, but his program had arrived. Two years later, NMH toppled Brewster – and a team that had future NBA players TJ Warren and Mitch McGary coming off the bench – in the semifinals en route to a NEPSAC title.
For the next decade, the battles continued.
“The matchups at their place, the place was sold out. The matchups at our place, the gym was sweating,” Carroll said. “People coming from the neighborhood and the basketball world showing up in Gill, Massachusetts, to see two of the best teams in the United States play basketball. It was beyond what people could ever imagine. This little tiny town in Wolfesboro, New Hampshire, this show happening every year.”
NEW MAG: Read our Winter 2026 issue
Along the way, mutual respect formed. Carroll pored through film, podcasts and books in an effort to figure out how to gain an advantage on his rival. Smith said Carroll made him a better coach; stealing plays and philosophies was a sign of respect.
Smith won seven national prep championships and seven NEPSAC championships at Brewster, while Carroll won four NEPSAC titles and one national prep crown at NMH. They both had incredible success placing their players into college basketball.
But joining forces? That seemed like a pipe dream.
“Not a chance,” Carroll said.
Smith learned never to say never to anything. But it still seemed unlikely.
“I was at my place for 21 years, he was at his place for 26 years,” Carroll said. “Neither one of us ever thought we would leave where we were.”
A big idea
It was during the height of their rivalry that Carroll started thinking about the possibility of a sports academy in New England. Smith said the two even talked about it around 10 years ago, when there were rumors that IMG Academy – the sports academy in Florida – could regionalize.
It never did, but the idea lingered.
“JC and I had conversations that if a sports academy comes to New England, that could really change things,” Smith said.
Why? Carroll said the market was changing. Traditional prep schools, while providing great experiences that translated to student-athlete success, had their limits.
“The market wants more,” Carroll explained. “They want more access, they want more training, they want more strength, they want more mental performance, they want nutrition, they want recovery. …
“I was worried. I saw the shift in the market and I saw the resistance to give in to that market. That worried me. If a sports academy came in and they were a willing participant and matching and meeting the market’s desires, it would really cause concern for my program and where I was working, because the market wanted more.”
So when Peter Masters, the founder of MAI, reached out to Carroll four years ago about his vision, presenting him with designs of what the school would look like, Carroll didn’t need any convincing. Carroll – who left NMH in 2022 and then became an advisor at Newman – was all in.
Then, when the time came this year to hire a head coach, he knew Smith would be the right man for the job.
“I think he is the best coach in the United States,” Carroll said. “And I think he’s certainly the best coach to run a team with the ambitions and guidelines and opportunities and resources that we have and we’re going to have at Masters. I thought he was perfect.”
Smith spent 26 seasons at Brewster building the Bobcats into a national powerhouse. But he said the decision to leave that behind wasn’t necessarily difficult. The opportunity at MAI was too much.
“I was more excited about what Masters could become,” Smith said.
Unlimited possibilities
Everything fell into place with the transition to MAI. Smith was happy that he could bring the new sports academy into the Nike EYBL Scholastic – considered the top high school league in the country – and he was able to bring his staff with him, including Josh Lee and Naadir Tharpe, with Tharpe coaching MAI’s prep team that will compete in the NEBL.
Carroll said there’s been a figuring-out process, because the way he and Smith go about things is different. In recruiting, for example, Smith is more patient, while Carroll is eager to complete his roster. The resources they use are different. They try to cater to each other’s strengths. Carroll said he’s yielded way more to Smith than he would with any other coach.
“I want to serve him as much as possible, I want this to be his program as much as possible, and yet there’s a standard and vision I have for the program,” Carroll said. “Figuring out the negotiation between us has been fun to figure out. …
“We’re building the plane as we fly it a little bit, but the bottom line is there’s expertise behind it. .. We trust each other’s ability to deliver. I’m excited for every day that we work together. But I’m really excited about three years from now, two years from now, where everything starts to connect.”
Upon being hired, Smith proceeded to build a roster for both his EYBL and prep teams that are as good – if not better – than the rosters he put together at Brewster. Antonio Pemberton, the top-ranked player in New England who spent the last two seasons with him at Brewster, was the first domino to fall. Filling out the rest of the roster was a unique experience, because the school’s construction hadn’t been completed yet.
“People visiting weren’t necessarily seeing a completed school or completed building,” Smith said. “It was essentially a construction site. You had to communicate a little bit more about what the plan was going to be and what it was going to look like when it was done.”
MAI: 10 boys prospects to watch in sports academy's first season
MAI’s basketball facility is not complete – it broke ground on campus on Oct. 10 and the hope is for it to open next year. For this season, the teams will practice at the Millworks in nearby Westford and will play their home games at Maynard High School.
But the rest of the infrastructure is in place, and Carroll and Smith both say the experience has met expectations.
A student’s typical day at MAI is structured and operates with the sports schedule as a priority. For the basketball teams, 7 a.m. breakfasts are followed by their commute to the Millworks for a 7:50 practice session, with the workouts dependent on what day it is. Pliability and strength workouts are all built into the schedule. Lunch is then followed by class from roughly 1 p.m. to 5:15, followed by dinner and more player development work at night. Weekend schedules vary based on what’s happening that week and if there is travel required for games.
Carroll has especially been blown away by the positive relationship between athletics and academics at MAI. He said academics wrap around athletics, not the other way around. In his past experiences, there’s been friction between both departments, but it hasn’t existed at MAI. There are no tests and quizzes on Fridays because that is typically a travel day for games, and papers aren’t due on Mondays. They don’t have to base their athletic schedules on when class times are. Everyone is aligned.
“I can’t tell you the impact on kids’ mental health and anxiety,” Carroll said. “We go to Vegas, we play three games (over a weekend), most schools would not make adjustments for athletes. The reality is these kids would have to do the homework on a red eye or in an airport in order to get their paper in. It’s everything I hoped it would be.”
Every part of the experience is tailored to maximize the students’ development and performance, including mental health and recovery. Carroll recruited Rich Casella to be the school’s head strength and conditioning coach, and he’s a game-changer. Casella is UMass basketball’s former strength coach who also spent time with Carroll at NMH and Newman.
That strength and conditioning work is important to Carroll.
“If you’re going to be a high school kid who hopes to get recruited and play in college, your body has to be right,” Carroll said. “There’s no wiggle room for that. You can’t be just a great basketball player and not have your body prepared. If we’re going to be a sports academy, we needed to have someone who understood they had to put a suit of armor on these kids before they get to college.”
Both Carroll and Smith are, naturally, ecstatic about the future and the possibilities that could come at MAI. The school has more than 300 students in Year 1 despite the fact that it was under construction for most of the last year. From a basketball lens, Smith said there could be expansion to more teams as the basketball facility gets completed and the school continues to grow.
Ultimately, Carroll and Smith are hoping this sports academy helps make New England the best destination for basketball again, just like it was when they were coaching rivals.
“We were the leaders for a long, long time and the rest of the country has really become ambitious and they’re doing some interesting things, and they’ve taken that title from us,” Carroll said. “I want to be in a position where when they talk about the regions of basketball, that Masters helps bring the spotlight back to New England, where the best basketball in the country, the best preparation, the best college placement, everything that’s the best, is in New England.
“We want it to be because of Masters.”


