In Part 1 of our inaugural NEPSAC boys coaches’ survey, we asked the coaches about who they think are the league’s best and most underrated players entering the 2025-26 season.
Now, we switch focus to the teams.
As the start of the school year fast approaches, rosters around NEPSAC are generally set, save for a few last-minute additions or sudden departures for some who have reclassified to 2025 and are heading to college. Coaches had a good sense of who the league’s top contenders and sleepers were when we asked them in July.
The coaches were granted anonymity so they could voice opinions freely. The only requirement in this portion of the survey was that they could not answer with their own program.
Let’s dive into Part 2.
Who is the best boys team in your NEPSAC class?
We’ll start with Class AAA, where all of that class’ coaches answered with Newman. It’s not a surprise; the defending champions bring back five of their top nine rotation pieces from last season, including nationally-ranked recruits Lucas Morillo and Quinn Costello (Medford, Mass.).
The Cardinals are also adding Jaylen Hunter-Coleman (Boston, Mass.), who was out injured during the grassroots season but should give another boost to their dynamic backcourt that also included sharpshooter Chase Geremia (Madison, Conn.) and Louis O’Keefe.
“They return so much from a team that won NEPSAC last year,” one coach said. “They continue to have strong depth and pieces that fit well together. Offensively they are so hard to guard and defensively they have a ton of versatility.”
“Good retention and cohesion, deep roster and a lot of focus on game prep,” another coach said.
In Class AA, there was another runaway winner: Cushing.
The Penguins, last season’s AA regular-season champions and NEBL champions, return Ryan Moesch and Theo Edema, who coaches voted as the best point guard and big in NEPSAC, respectively, in Part 1 of our survey. Guard Brady O’Connell (Bedford, N.H.), a lockdown defender, wing Elliot Erickson (Gardner, Mass.) and 7-footer Coley Mark are also back.
“Hard to argue against Cushing with what they’re bringing back,” one coach said.
Head coach James Cormier surrounded them with dynamic weapons, too. Roxbury Latin postgraduate transfer Jack Hynes (Milton, Mass.) is a do-it-all wing, Jake Nosek is versatile and Tilton transfer Anthony Vick (Boston, Mass.) is a high-level shotmaker. Nate Blenman, a 6-foot-9 transfer who suffered an injury at the start of the spring, is also now cleared to return and the coaching staff is very excited about him. They will be the team to beat.
“Talent and very well-coached,” one coach said of Cushing.
“Best point guard/big man combination,” another coach said. “Terrific shooting around those two.”
One coach gave a nod to Kimball Union in Class AA, The Wildcats have an intriguing roster that includes Marist commit Brandon Arnold and big man Merrick Smith (Belgrade, Maine) under head coach Cory McClure.
“Good size and depth, great coach,” the coach said.
Class A netted a mix of answers. Despite losing four starters from last season’s championship team, several coaches still picked Williston Northampton as the best in the class.
“I would assume they will reload to defend their title,” one coach said.
Two key Class of 2027 pieces from last season’s title squad, 6-foot-3 point guard Max Kellogg (Amherst, Mass.) and 6-foot-11 forward Kyle Seltzer, are back to defend their crown. Head coach Ben Farmer is also excited about the addition of transfer guard Jerry Johnson Jr.
“Top level coaching, size and skill down low, good guard play, little bit of everything,” one coach said.
“Great coach that knows how to win,” another coach said.
Choate and Hotchkiss earned several votes, and one coach couldn’t pick between the two. Choate graduated All-NEPSAC choices Aliaun Iscandari, Quintin Floyd and Jake Palluzzi, head coach Drew Dawson brings back guard Jack Stevens and has great depth and size with Landon Geren, Hunter Stoll and Yale commit Brady Wooley. Meanwhile, Hotchkiss has exciting potential behind Harvard commit Preston Merrick and Alonzo Archbold.
“Most talent and depth heading into the season,” one coach said of Choate and Hotchkiss. “Good coaches.”
“Well-coached and blend of talent,” another said of Choate.
Phillips Andover, Tabor, Deerfield and Milton Academy are among the other teams that earned a shout in Class A.
In Class B, one coach was stumped.
“Class B is so up in the air,” the coach said. “Truly a good question.”
The class is wide open, but several coaches are high on St. Mark’s. The Lions, led by head coach Justin Perron, made their first playoff appearance in a decade last season and brought back a core of guards Alex Echevarria and CJ Farrell (Milford, Mass.) alongside versatile big Luca Palermo (Andover, Mass.).
“They return a good number of their core players from last year and have added a few solid pieces in the offseason,” one coach said. “And they're very well coached.”
There’s faith that Rivers, even after graduating the core of its dynastic run the last four years, will retool as a contender under head coach Keith Zalaski. The Red Wings earned multiple votes as coaches cited their young talent. Rising sophomore Pat Costello (Natick, Mass.), who starred as a freshman, is back alongside 2027 additions Jack Millward (Wakefield, Mass.) and Ikenna Okafor (Easton, Mass.). Rising senior Chais Harriette (Mattapan, Mass.) looked good at the NEPSAC showcases, too, and is expected to make a leap as the starting point guard.
“Fantastic coach with a culture that is intact,” one coach said of Rivers. “Reloaded with some younger talent that will make an immediate impact in Class B.”
GIRLS COACHES' SURVEYS: Part 1 on best players | Part 2 on best teams
What NEPSAC team will take a leap next season?
This question yielded a strong mix of answers, expectedly. Class AAA was led by Darrow, which finished third in its first season in the class last year and figures to make another jump under head coach Antonio Anderson. The Ducks return Hunter Te Ratana, Haisi Mayben, Nalajah Christopher (Worcester, Mass.) and a flurry of exciting transfers, including Jamison Thrower and TJ Allen (Watertown, Mass.).
“They will continue to ride the positive momentum from Year 1 and return a lot of key pieces,” one coach said. “They play extremely fast which will cause some teams trouble. Another team with depth that can beat you a variety of different ways.”
“I think Darrow will be good again (and) continue to move in the right direction,” another coach added.
Vermont Academy earned multiple votes. One coach lauded head coach John Zall, who they believe is hungry. The Wildcats return All-NEPSAC selection Kamari Whyte alongside exciting pieces in 6-foot-7 Filip Mozoul and 6-foot-8 Landon Whiting.
“Well-coached and return some key guys who had big roles last season,” one coach said.
South Kent also earned a vote for Class AAA.
Eight teams earned votes in Class AA, starting with Kimball Union.
“Cory has all the pieces to make a run,” one coach said.
Wilbraham & Monson, which snuck into the playoffs last season, earned one coach’s vote. Sam Fleming (Springfield, Mass.), one of the best wings in the region who suffered a season-ending injury last season, is back in action. Christian Martin (Amherst, Mass.), one of New England’s best 3-point shooters, and long 6-foot-7 wing Chinedu Okpara give head coach Mike Mannix a fun trio to work with.
“Lots of quality veterans returning,” the coach said. “Several scholarship level prospects.”
Brimmer & May got a shout from one coach, who said head coach Tom Nelson will have them fighting for the playoffs and their big three of Windston Legentus (Raynham, Mass.), Ladanion Payne (Mattapan, Mass.) and Tyson Robinson (Newton, Mass.) will be tough to beat. The same coach said “everyone seems to be high” on Tilton after former coach Marcus O’Neil returned for his second stint with the program. O’Neil led the Rams to six New England championships, the 2009 national prep championship and coached several future NBA players in his first 15-year stint at the school.
Lawrence Academy, last season’s final playoff team, got a shout for its experienced returners, including star Alex Egbuonu (Nashua, N.H.), who coaches picked as the best player in NEPSAC. MacDuffie, Cushing and new NEPSAC addition Albany Academy all earned a vote.
Class A was split between four schools. Multiple coaches are high on Suffield, Brunswick and Deerfield.
Suffield is an early Class A contender after a promising showing at June’s NEPSAC showcases. Led by head coach Drew Gamere, his squad includes Markus Maxwell-Grimes – who might be the most underrated guard in the league – and dynamic 6-foot-10 big Jakub Lomicka.
“They have a great point guard who stayed committed for years,” one coach said of Maxwell-Grimes.
Brunswick is also an under-the-radar sleeper. Rhaki Lum earned votes as the most underrated player in NEPSAC in Part 1 of our survey, and he’s surrounded by an experienced cast that includes Connor Robinson and Jaylen Johnson.
“A lot of returners. very good guard play,” one coach said.
One coach gave Austin Prep some recognition. Marvin Avery (Lynn, Mass.) leads head coach Sean Ryan's group as a sleeper guard who turned heads last season in his NEPSAC debut.
“Good coaching and they continue to add pieces,” the coach said. “Their record has never shown how good they are; this year that will happen.”
In Class B, one coach was particularly high on St. Luke’s, which showed some promise last season. Tyler Newsom (Monroe, Conn.), who looked strong at the NEPSAC showcases as an athletic 6-foot-5 guard, leads a group that brings back some experience.
“Another year older, good coaching with enough athletes, size and shotmaking to make the jump,” the coach said.
Westminster received love here, and St. Mark’s got some more recognition as a breakout candidate.
“St. Mark's returns just about everyone, has two elite guards that play both ways, Palermo healthy and in shape,” the coach said. “(They) will be much improved and they have positional size and depth to contend in B.”


